….the best I can do does not do the place much justice in the way of beauty. - Tom Thomson, letter to Dr. James MacCallum, Oct. 6, 1914, from Canoe Lake Station (MacCallum Papers, National Gallery of Canada Archives).
Take everything as it comes; the wave passes, deal with the next one — Tom Thomson, 1877-1917
Thomson had caught the bug of the North. He soon showed up at work carrying a new paddle, which he immediately tested out by filling one of the photoengraver tanks with water, then placing the tank beside his chair so he could sit down and practise paddling.
“At each stroke he gave a real canoeman’s twist,” recalled J.E.H. MacDonald, “and his eye had a quiet gleam, as if he saw the hills and shores of Canoe Lake.” - from Northern Light: The Enduring Mystery of Tom Thomson and the Woman Who Loved Him by Roy MacGregor, p. 28
….“Mark,” he says, “they found Tom Thomson’s canoe, and it’s floating upside down, just in back here, just back this direction, in there against the shore.” Now the water was not near as high as it is now and how that canoe got in there in that condition it was I’ll never know, or anybody else I guess. However, in the Algonquin Story it tells you the canoe was floating right side up. That’s absolutely false. I’m the man that took that canoe and turned it over and examined what was in the canoe; there was none of his equipment in it -…his little axe even was gone – and the paddles were tied in for carrying – his paddle that he used in paddling was not there. If he’d had it with him, we never found it afterwards…. - Mark Robinson, from an interview he gave at Taylor Statten Camp, Oct. 1956 (from Death On A Painted Lake: The Tom Thomson Tragedy).
A few years back I was at THEMUSEUM in Kitchener….and did a presentation as part of the Searching For Tom art show….my talk was on Tom’s canoe….and I was happy to share some of the information I had gathered about Tom’s canoe….as well as the role of the canoe and paddling in his art and his life…..between 40 and 50 people came out to hear this ‘heritage canoe expert’, or as I explained ‘heritage canoe’ means ‘old canoe’ and I’m an ‘old guy who paddles’….as for ‘expert’, that’s actually an ‘ex-spurt’ or ‘former drip under pressure’. My talk was based on the information I gathered for previous blog entries here….as well as an article I did for Canoeroots. I was asked by a few that attended (and some who couldn’t) to post the text of my talk on Tom Thomson’s canoe….so here is the main parts of the talk I gave (as well as the photos I used)….hope you enjoy:
Tom Thomson: The Artist And The Canoe
The artist and the canoe: when one thinks of canoeing and Canadian art, what readily comes to mind is Tom Thomson.
After 1900, the canoe was not merely something identified with Native people or the fur-trade and exploration. This was the Golden Age of the canoe. Canoes were being used for recreation, especially hunting and fishing. The canoe was necessary to travel into wild places like Algonquin Park. Tom Thomson fell in love with Algonquin Park from the moment he first visited there in 1912. He spent as much time as possible there over the next five years of his life. If not painting or sketching, he took whatever work he could to make ends meet, even briefly as a park ranger and a guide. Often he was off on a canoe trip, portaging into remote lakes and camping out under the stars. So the canoe is central to the work of Tom Thomson. Tom Thomson became known for his skill with a paddle as well as with a brush.
![TT1 - Tom Thomson]()
Title: Tom Thomson Creator: Unknown Archive or Repository: Library and Archives Canada/Bibliotheque et Archives Canada Collection or Fond: Lawren Stewart Harris fonds Reference Number: PA-121719, Box T2509
![TT2 - Tom Thomson On Canoe Lake]()
Title: Tom Thomson on Canoe Lake Creator: UnknownArchive or Repository: Archives of OntarioCollection or Fond: William Colgate collection Reference Number: F1066/I0010309
![TT3 - Tom Thomson Fishing]()
Title: Tom Thomson fishing Creator: Unknown Archive or Repository: Archives of Ontario Collection or Fond: William Colgate collection Reference Number: F 1066-6/I0010312 Notes: An iconic image of Thomson fishing below one of the dams created to help move lumber from lake to lake in Algonquin Park.
![TT4 - Canoeists Campsite]()
Canoeist’s camp by Tom Thomson, from Library and Archives Canada, Reference Number: PA-193562 Notes: This photo may have been taken by Thomson on his trip through the Mississagi (Provincial) Forest Reserve, Northern Ontario, in summer 1912. The negative has been damaged, explaining the distorted nature of the image.
![TT5 - Tom Shaving]()
Title: Tom Thomson, a member of the Group of Seven, shaving after coming out of the woods with a beard Creator: Unknown [Ed Godin?] Archive or Repository: Library and Archives Canada/Bibliotheque et Archives Canada Reference Number: C-007900 Notes: Library and Archives Canada notes this photo was created at Grand Lake. Achray is located on Grand Lake, which was where Ed Godin was working as a Park Ranger in 1916. Thomson would stay with Godin at times during the summer of 1916, painting a sign to hang over the entrance to Godin’s shack. Note: The title this image is filed under in Library and Archives Canada is incorrect. Thomson was never a member of the Group of Seven, which was formed in 1920, three years after Thomson’s death.
![TT6 - Canoe Lake Map]()
Title: Canoe Lake (and vicinity), Algonquin Park, Ontario Creator: William Little Pages: vi Notes: 1. Original Thomson gravesite. 2. Thomson’s body recovered. 3. Mowat Lodge 4. Winnie Trainor’s cottage 5. The Bletcher cotttage 6. Gill Lake portage 7. Alternate Gill Lake portage 8. Guide’s cabin 9. Canoe Lake train station 10. Mark Robinson’s house 11. Algonquin Hotel 12. Coulson’s store 13. Joe Lake dam 14. Favourite camping site of Thomson’s 15. Thomson cairn (also a favourite Thomson camping site) 16. Thomson’s canoe found
![TT7 - Artist's Sketch of Winnie Trainor]()
Sketch of Winnie Trainor, who was believed to be engaged to marry Tom Thomson, by Victoria Lywood, John Abbott College, from Northern Light: The Enduring Mystery of Tom Thomson and the Woman Who Loved Him by Roy MacGregor
![TT8 - Shannon Fraser, Annie Fraser, And Others]()
Title: Shannon Fraser, Annie Fraser, and others Creator: Unknown Archive or Repository: Algonquin Park Archives Reference Number: APMA 48 Notes: Shannon and Annie Fraser on left side.
![TT9 - Annie Fraser In Front Of Fire Place Mowat Lodge]()
Title: Annie Fraser, in front of Mowat Lodge fireplace Creator: Unknown Archive or Repository: Algonquin Park Archives Reference Number: APMA 1016
![TT10 - Shannon Fraser]()
Title: Shannon Fraser, with “The Hearse” Creator: Unknown Archive or Repository: Algonquin Park Archives Reference Number: APMA 3010
![TT11 - Mowat Lodge]()
Title: Mowat Lodge Creator: Unknown Archive or Repository: Algonquin Park Archives Reference Number: APMA 186 Notes: Mowat Lodge, how it appeared during the period Thomson was visiting Canoe Lake. The Lodge is where Thomson often stayed when he was not camping in the Park.
![TT12 - Mowat Lodge 1920s, Seen From Across Water]()
Title: Mowat Lodge Creator: Unknown Archive or Repository: Algonquin Park Archives Reference Number: APMA 222 Notes: Mowat Lodge, seen across the water during the 1920s.
![TT13 - Fraser's Lodge (Mowat Lodge), Tom thomson]()
Title: Fraser’s Lodge (Mowat Lodge) Creator: Tom Thomson Archive or Repository: Art Gallery of Alberta Collection or Fond: Art Gallery of Alberta collection Reference Number: 77.30 Notes: Oil on wood, 21.9 x 27 cm. Gift of Mrs. Gertrude Poole, 1977.
![TT14 - George Rowe]()
Title: George Rowe and group Creator: Unknown Archive or Repository: Algonquin Park Archives Reference Number: APMA 5084 Notes: George Rowe, who worked as an Algonquin Park guide out of Mowat at the same time as Thomson was there, is in the back row, far left. Rowe was one of the men who brought Thomson’s body in to shore upon its discovery in the lake.
![TT15 - Canoe Lake From Mowat Cemetary]()
Title: Canoe Lake, seen from Mowat cemetery Creator: Unknown Archive or Repository: Algonquin Park Archives Reference Number: APMA 6932 Notes: Mowat Lodge is visible at far right.
![TT16 - Canoe Lake Station]()
Title: Canoe Lake station Creator: Unknown Archive or Repository: Algonquin Park Archives Reference Number: APMA 2039
![TT17 - Canoe Lake Station, Looking West]()
Title: Canoe Lake station Creator: Unknown Archive or Repository: Algonquin Park Archives Reference Number: APMA 5905 Notes: Looking west towards Canoe Lake station.
![TT18 - Going to Canoe Lake For Mail]()
Title: Going to Canoe Lake station for the mail Creator: Unknown Archive or Repository: Algonquin Park Archives Reference Number: APMA 2500 Notes: The lady seated in the sled is Daphne Crombie, who would later confess some provocative information she claimed Annie Fraser had told her about Tom Thomson and Winnifred Trainor’s relationship. Mowat Lodge, operated by the Frasers, can be seen in the background.
![TT19 - Guide's License]()
Algonquin Park Guide’s License — Tom Thomson, from Algonquin Park Archives, Reference Number: APMA 185 Notes: Original document is held by Library and Archives Canada.
![TT20 - Warrant To Bury]()
Title: Warrant to Bury After A View Creator: A. E. Ranney, M. D. Archive or Repository: Archives of Ontario Reference Number: I0029100 Notes: This form was filled out by Dr. Ranney, the coroner presiding over the Thomson inquest. It indicates that an inquest had been held into Tom Thomson’s death, and that Ranney gave permission for Thomson’s corpse to be buried. The statement made on the form is not entirely true, however. By the time Ranney arrived in Mowat, Thomson’s body had already been buried. The doctor never actually viewed Thomson’s remains.
![TT21 - Coroner's Warrant]()
Title: Coroner’s warrant to take possession of body Creator: A. E. Ranney, M. D. Archive or Repository: Archives of Ontario Reference Number: I0029101 Notes: This form, signed by Dr. Ranney, the Coroner presiding over the Thomson case, gave permission for the body of Thomson to be released to the Chief Constable of the District of Nipissing. By the time Ranney signed this document, however, Thomson’s corpse had already been laid to rest in a grave in Mowat cemetery.
Few Thomson paintings actually have canoes in them. When he did depict a canoe, it seemed to be just part of the scenery. One such painting, simply entitled The Canoe, shows a lone grey canoe on the shore of a northern lake. But by looking at most of Tom’s smaller sketches, it is apparent that these were created from a canoeist’s perspective. Thomson often painted while he was in a canoe. Tom included the image of a grey canoe in a couple of his paintings….could this be the same grey canoe as shown in the above photo. In December 2005 Joyner Waddington held an auction of works by Lawren Harris (a member of the Group of Seven) and Tom Thomson. These included a little-known oil sketch, by Tom entitled Canoe and Lake, Algonquin Park, which sold for $369,600 (now that would have bought a pile of Chestnut canoes LOL LOL).
![TT22 - Tom Thomson Canoe and Lake, Algonquin Park 1913 oil on canvas]()
Image of Tom Thomson’s ‘Canoe and Lake, Algonquin Park’ courtesy Joyner Waddington, http://www.joyner.ca/pages/joyner-auctions/viewlot.php?id=1000696. Title: Canoe And Lake, Algonquin Park, oil on canvas, laid down on panel, signed Creator: Tom Thomson 7 ins x 10 ins; 17.5 cms x 25 cms EST. $80,000 / 100,000 PRICE: $377,100.00 Painted circa 1912-13. Provenance: Private Collection, Toronto Literature: Dennis Reid and Charles C. Hill, Tom Thomson, Art Gallery of Ontario and National Gallery of Canada, Toronto and Ottawa, 2002, pages 157-169, colour plates 5-17 for related Algonquin works from the same period and of similar size and medium, in particular, for a painting entitled The Canoe (plate 6). This work was included in Joan Murray’s catalogue raisonne of the artist’s work.
Tom Thomson also painted The Canoe in 1914, which is now in the Art Gallery of Ontario, yet another depiction of a grey canoe in Algonquin Park.
![TT23 - The Canoe, Tom Thomson]()
Image from Group of Seven Art.com, a fine arts reproduction company,http://www.groupofsevenart.com/Thomson/Images/Tom_Thomson_The_Canoe_1912_GS.jpg. Note: This image incorrectly identifies this painting as from 1912.
![TT24 - Canoe Lake, Tom Thomson]()
Title: Canoe Lake, Algonquin Park Creator: Tom Thomson Archive or Repository: Macdonald Stewart Art Centre Collection or Fond: University of Guelph Collection Reference Number: MSAC-UG989.097 Notes: Oil on canvas. Gift of Stewart and Letty Bennett, donated by the Ontario Heritage Foundation to the University of Guelph, 1988.
![TT25 - Chill November, Tom Thomson]()
Title: Chill November Creator: Tom Thomson Archive or Repository: Gallery Lambton Collection or Fond: Gallery Lambton Notes: Oil on canvas, 36″ x 42″/91.4 cm x 106.7 cm. Gift of the Sarnia Women’s Conservation Art Association, 1956.
![TT26 - Tom's Studio, Toronto]()
Title: Tom Thomson studio (exterior), Toronto Creator: Unknown Archive or Repository: Archives of Ontario Collection or Fond: William Colgate collection Reference Number: F1066/I0010308.jpg Notes: This photograph gives a sense of the shack Tom Thomson used as a studio in Toronto. The shack was located adjacent to the studio building Dr. James MacCallum and Lawren Harris erected on Severn Street.
![TT27 - Tom Thomson Plaque]()
Title: Plaque, Tom Thomson Memorial Cairn, Hayhurst Point, Canoe Lake, Algonquin Park Creator: Ben Greisman
![TT28 - Tom Thomson 1877-1917 - Canoe Lake, Algonquin]()
Title: Tom Thomson 1877-1917, Canoe Lake, Algonquin sign
In July 1917, a a very distinctive blue-grey canoe was found floating upside down, with a paddle lashed inside as if ready to portage, in Canoe Lake. A week later, the body of Tom Thomson was also discovered, with fishing line wrapped around him. As in life, a canoe figured in his demise, maybe even in more than one way. Tom Thomson’s death is a mystery. Suggestions range from Tom falling out of his canoe, bumping his head and then had drowning, to foul play and even suicide. I believe it was foul play, and quite possible that Tom was killed over an outstanding loan of $250 he had made to Shannon Fraser for the purchase of canoes (it could be Tom needed the money for his upcoming marriage to Winnie Trainor).
Whatever the case, a canoe is part of the tale. Even through name of the lake where he died in. Stories of a ghostly canoeist have become part of the legacy of Tom Thomson, said to be seen by Lawren Harris among others. But for all of the intrigue involved, Tom’s art speaks for itself. And his canoe is part of that too. So what do we know of the artist’s canoe? In a letter to Tom’s brother, George Thomson, from Winifred Trainor (a local Algonquin Park woman that Tom Thomson was to marry): “….in July 1915 Tom bought a new chestnut canoe silk tent etc…” Dr. R.P. Little states in his recollection of Tom Thomson: “What a horse is to a cowboy, a 16-foot canvas-covered canoe was to Tom. (This canoe was made by the Chestnut Canoe Company of New Brunswick.)” Another source describes that “Tom took great pride in his own Chestnut-brand canoe, which, like a centaur, was almost part of him. The story is told of how he added a whole tube of very expensive artist’s paint to a can of canoe enamel in order to get the exact shade that he wanted.” As for the canoe’s unique colour, there is no doubt that Tom thomson’s canoe was grey blue in colour. Apparently the colour was the result of Tom’s own creation….one source states: “The canoe was distinctive with a metal strip along the keel and painted a grey-green of Tom’s concoction. The small population of Canoe Lake must have known it by sight”….another reference says: “Thomsom had a canoe in which he took great pride, a graceful cedar and canvas Chestnut craft of a unique dove-grey colour, which he had achieved by adding a deluxe $2.00 tube of cobalt blue artist’s paint to a standard grey canoe paint.” So Tom Thomson had a customized blue or green-grey Chestnut canoe. As for what became of Tom Thomson’s canoe, it apparently disappeared. It is told that in 1930 (13 years after Tom’s death), 75 canoes, in various states of condition, were brought to Camp Ahmek to be reviewed by a group of local guides and experts to determine if any were Tom’s lost canoe. Mark Robinson, the park ranger who knew Tom Thomson well, was part of this panel. None of these canoes proved to be Tom’s canoe and they were apparently burned in the camp’s incinerator. Another rumour has a boys’ camp ending up with Tom’s canoe, where it fell into disrepair. Or that it was used as a spare canoe at the end of a portage in Algonquin so one didn’t have to carry over another canoe. It is even possible that Shannon Fraser used it at Mowat Lodge until it was abandoned or rotted away.
![TT29 - Arthur Lismer In Canoe With Tom Thomson]()
Arthur Lismer and Tom Thomson in a canoe, Canoe Lake, Algonquin Park, May 1914 (McMichael Canadian Art Collection Archives), fromhttp://www.images.technomuses.ca/swf/sublime/sublime_print_en_02.html.
![TT30- Tom Thomson In Gray Canoe]()
Tom Thomson in his “grey canoe”….Algonquin Park. Picture from Don Charbonneau’s website, http://doncharbonneau.com/fr_tomthomson.cfm.
From the picture of Tom Thomson in his canoe, I believe that the canoe is a Chestnut Cruiser or a Guides’ Special (that was a version of the Cruiser), likely 16 feet in length. It couldn’t be a Prospector since the Prospector didn’t appear until 1923. The Crusing Model was made in two grades, with the first grade being of better material and finish, with two cane seats; the second grade might have cedar that contained small knots, with a slightly heavier canvas and a waterproof finish to withstand heavier usage, painted in a dull grey slate, having one cane stern seat and a bar forward. The first grade 16 footer was appropriately named the Premier, while the second grade was named Kruger (after a prominent Boer War figure). The Cruising model was a larger canoe than the Pleasure model, “higher towards the ends, and designed for rougher water.” Because of a rounder hull and being slightly rockered, it was better suited for rivers or whitewater. The Guides’ Special had closer spaced ribs (even having half ribs in earlier models) to supposedly stiffen and strengthen the canoe, again for harder usage. The 16 foot Guides’ Special was known as the Boone. Early prices for a Cruiser ranged from $33 to $43, depending on grade, for the 16 foot length, with the same sized Guides’ Special at $38.
The first is from the 1904 catalog and is the Cruiser model. Next picture is the 1913 Guide model.
![TT31 - Chesnut Cruiser]()
The first is from the 1904 catalog and is the Cruiser model.
![chestnut%201913%20pleasure]()
Second is from the 1913 catalog and is the Pleasure model.
![chestnut%201913%20catalog%20page%2016]()
Third is a picture that comes after the Pleasure model in the catalog… one could presume it is the Pleasure but that isn’t stated. The angle is similar to the one in the picture of Thompson (spelling) in his canoe, and the two canoes appear to have similar lines.
![chestnut%201913%20guide]()
Fourth picture is the 1913 Guide model.
Images from the “Canadian Wood Canoe & Boat Company Catalog Collection” available on CD from http://www.wcha.org/catalog/ andhttp://www.dragonflycanoe.com/cdrom.htm on the web.
Whatever the canoe was that Tom Thomson paddled, it certainly is forever interwined with his art and his life.
I also included a poem I wrote regarding the Tom Thomson saga:
Ghost Canoe
Painted using a mixture of regular marine grey and an artist’s $2 tube of cobalt blue
There was little chance of mistaking Tom Thomson’s distinctive “dove grey” canoe
Yet when it was found floating upside down in Canoe Lake
Offshore and unattended, riding free in the wave’s wake
Little could anyone have realized the great mystery about to unfold
The legend and the lore of the man, the story that might never be told
Discovering Thomson’s body bobbing near Little Wapomeo Island
With a bruise over the temple, blood coming from the ear
Could this be the result of an argument that got out of hand?
At the very least finding Tom such had been the greatest fear
With so much talent and surely a prosperous future just ahead
It was sad that by July 1917, at age 39, Tom Thomson was dead
But would anybody ever know how he had met this terrible fate?
Over the years memories fade and facts become less than straight
What is to be made of the ankle wrapped around with fishing line?
Was Tom killed by a waterborne whirlwind or likewise divine?
And what ever became of the missing favourite paddle?
So much that is hard to fathom or begin to try to straddle
What of the two paddles lashed inside the canoe as if ready to carry
But apparently haphazardly tied in with less than an expert’s knot?
Had Thomson decided to head out west, to leave without further tarry?
Was a loan to Shannon Fraser involved, a debt for canoes recently bought?
Were harsh words over the war with Germany allowed to enflame?
Was Martin Blecher (or was it Bletcher?) that was the one to blame?
Would the truth ever come out of what had happened to the artist cum guide
Had he drowned standing up attempting to pee over the canoe’s side?
Was it a case of possible foul play or even suicide?
Had Tom Thomson gone missing due to a matter of family pride?
Had he promised Winnie Trainor that they would wed?
Or was his death the result of a fatal blow to the head?
Was there a baby that was soon to be due?
And who really last saw Tom in his canoe?
What is to be made of the report of the artist’s frequent swings in mood?
Was Thomson a gentleman, true in his word, or a drunkard sometimes crude?
Was he happy or sad? Was he bi-polar or even depressed?
So much remains unknown and never properly addressed
The coroner arrived after Tom had been embalmed and already buried
Holding a brief inquest that found death to have been accidental drowning
When to some such a finding seemed at the very least somewhat hurried
Even the coroner’s report becoming lost can only leave one frowning
What of the bruise on the temple? Was it on the left or the right?
Surely there must have been talk from the locals of a possible fight?
Accidental drowning may have been the official word
But this just seems far too simple and even absurd
Most thought Tom was more than adequate in the water; it was known he could swim
He was also considered a good enough paddler to keep any canoe reasonably trim
No water in his lungs? So long for the body to surface? Did something prevent it to rise?
Too many questions for such a quick report….too much unanswered to just surmise
What of the questions of the actual burial site? Is Tom in Leith or at Canoe Lake?
Was there really a body in that sealed metal casket? Or merely sand meant to fake?
Why has the family never allowed exhumation? Was undertaker Churchill sly as a fox?
Who was dug up in 1956? Thomson or someone of Native descent left in the same box?
Why did Miss Trainor continue to place flowers on a supposedly empty grave?
Baffling and puzzling to say the least….enough to make some even rant and rave.
But through all that is written, whatever theories may be, no matter all that has been told
Whether far too many questions still remain or how much this mystery may take a hold
To me one thing constant through all of this is the spiritual image of the canoe
Canoes appear in his art, even that distinctive Chestnut, painted grey blue
A canoe was involved in his death and in the name of the lake where he lost his life
Maybe from a debt over the purchase of canoes, money he needed to take a wife?
A ghostly figure has been seen on misty mornings paddling a canoe on Canoe Lake
But a silent, even benign ghost, hardly scary enough to keep one up nights wide awake
So canoes weave in out of Tom Thomson’s story; he even often painted from a canoe
But what became of his beloved Chestnut, with metal strip down the keel, and grey blue
Little is known where it ended up; maybe rotting at Mowat Lodge or on a portage trail?
Years after Tom’s death, a local camp even tried to locate this canoe, but alas to no avail
Painted using a mixture of regular marine grey and an artist’s $2 tube of cobalt blue
There was little chance of mistaking Tom Thomson’s distinctive “dove grey” canoe
Yet when it was found floating upside down in Canoe Lake
Offshore and unattended, riding free in the wave’s wake
Little could anyone have realized the great mystery about to unfold
The legend and the lore of the man, the story that might never be told
And while that canoe would become like the figure of a ghost
It is always part of Thomson’s art and life, playing no small role
Not just involved in a bit part, and certainly one larger than most
Maybe it was finally lost in time, but is always seen as in the whole
To some it might appear to be just another canoe, making no difference in any way
But to those who knew it could only be Tom Thomson’s Chestnut of blue grey
Painted using a mixture of regular marine grey and an artist’s $2 tube of cobalt blue
There was little chance of mistaking Tom Thomson’s distinctive “dove grey” canoe
Yet when it was found floating upside down in Canoe Lake
Offshore and unattended, riding free in the wave’s wake
Little could anyone have realized the great mystery about to unfold
The legend and the lore of the man, the story that might never be told